Today’s announcement that PayPal has partnered with Discover Card, another closed loop payment company – but in retail, could mark a game changing scenario in the land grab for alternative payments in retail. While Discover certainly doesn’t have the reach of Visa and Mastercard, it does provide a significant boost to PayPal’s merchant acquiring network. This is a smart move for both companies since Discover is the network that lags behind the others in terms of acceptance and issuance, and PayPal knew that it couldn’t win the game by organically acquiring its merchants.
Still, as an ex-PayPal Mobile exec and as someone who has used the PayPal payment at Home Depot, I believe the user experience is flawed. Having the consumer type in their mobile number and PIN is an experience that derives from a technology solution that stands without the need for partnerships and significant POS upgrades rather than the right consumer experience. The problem with the mobile number and PIN method is that it goes against the grain of the user behavior everyone else in the industry is promoting (card swipe, bar code off the phone, and NFC). This leaves PayPal alone in building that behavior which is very heavy lifting, and one that would require a SIGNIFICANT value proposition to the convince consumers to try – a value proposition well beyond what is provided by PayPal today. Can PayPal pull this off? PayPal has never been known to really understand their consumer base. They never had to as they could ride on the coat tails of eBay to get their first 50+ million users. Or will PayPal finally shift into the technology handshakes that are promoted by the industry? Starbucks and the airlines finally got us all used to the barcode on the phone. Will PayPal finally adopt this handshake? Or do they believe that the laser required to read the bar code is too much of a hurdle for its now Discover merchants to buy into (let alone NFC POS readers)?
While the Discover deal is a huge boost on the merchant side, it’s now time to focus on the consumer. Let’s see whether PayPal makes a drastic change to the consumer experience as well. An Apple deal would be the perfect marriage, but perhaps too uncharacteristic for Apple…
- Finally! Walmart launches #moneytranfers.In Mexico, Walmt has bank license. Wonder how long until #mobileremittances m.csmonitor.com/Business/Lates… 5 days ago
- @wayan_vota @mSolutionsUSAID Thanks so much! 1 week ago
- @wayan_vota @mSolutionsUSAID Thanks, Wayan! 1 week ago
- My latest blog: Early days for PayPal Mobile, bKash, and What's next in #MobileFinancialServices: mobilepayments.wordpress.com/2014/04/14/fro… 1 week ago
- @wayan_vota @mSolutionsUSAID @gsmammu @PursarPay Will check out. Thanks! 1 week ago
- Congrats to KopoKopo! #mpayments app.news.gsma.com/e/es?s=667&e=2… 1 week ago
- Listening to Kamal Quadir tell story about bKash at #DigitalFinance. Honored to helped out in early days of #bKash! Now at 12 mill users! 2 weeks ago
- Very smart move by Leaf to position as broker/advisor in POS/#mPayments innovation/chaos. pymnts.com/exclusive-seri… 2 weeks ago
- RT @wayan_vota: Whoa! Check out spread of #mobilemoney! So many countries w/ 3+ players, yet #mPesa still dominates ow.ly/i/56X4J … 2 weeks ago
- @mpayconnect re: MCX & Visa: Ps. April Fools! 3 weeks ago